Garcia to Smith · defect-report.pdf attached. Sending does not establish receipt or reading.
Matter intelligence
Availability: Limited availability
Find the proof. See what’s missing.
Source-linked chronologies and fact-to-element matrices connect the record to what you need to prove. Carry that work into discovery and deposition prep.
Availability details
A new document version flags pending approvals, client updates and research memos. A finished draft is flagged when a fact it cites is corrected, not when a document it cites changes.
What does the record say about notice?
Written notice of a defect within 30 days of delivery
Supply agreement · §9.2Garcia sent Smith the defect report on May 2.
defect-email.eml · May 2, 2025, 9:14 AMThe send date does not establish receipt or reading.
Smith testified the supplier learned of the defect “Only after May 4.”
Smith Dep. 44:12–20When did Smith receive or read the email?
Seek Smith’s copy and delivery recordsWhat does the record say about notice?
Written notice of a defect within 30 days of delivery
Supply agreement · §9.2Garcia sent Smith the defect report on May 2.
defect-email.eml · May 2, 2025, 9:14 AMThe send date does not establish receipt or reading.
Smith testified the supplier learned of the defect “Only after May 4.”
Smith Dep. 44:12–20When did Smith receive or read the email?
Seek Smith’s copy and delivery recordsInspect the full product example
Inspect the accounts and the evidence question
About this example
Explore this feature
In practice
See what the case rests on.
Build the source-linked chronology.
Read dated events beside their sources. Open the account behind each entry and compare the sequence before the next examination.
BRON / Matter record01North Harbor / noticeDisputedChronology
Agreement §9.2Notice by May 4, 2025- Garcia sent the defect report to Smith
defect-email.eml
May 2, 2025, 9:14 AM · defect-report.pdf attached. The email does not establish when Smith received or read it.
- Garcia testified the supplier knew before May 4
Garcia Dep. 118:4–12
“Before May 4.” The supplier knew of the defect before May 4. Garcia attended the review meeting.
- Smith testified the supplier knew only after May 4
Smith Dep. 44:12–20
“Only after May 4.” The supplier knew of the defect only after May 4. Smith relies on correspondence he reviewed.
Still openWhen Smith received or read the emailInspect the source passage
Deposition excerpt
Garcia’s account.
118:4–12“Before May 4.”
Garcia depositionPage and line recordedIssue and context
The reviewed issue it bears on
Was written notice of the defect given by May 4, 2025?
The supplier knew of the defect before May 4. Garcia attended the review meeting. Counsel checks the notice requirement and what this account establishes.North Harbor · Notice of defect · Illustration · fictional matter - Garcia sent the defect report to Smith
See the fact-to-element matrix.
Put the requirement beside supporting facts, adverse accounts and missing proof. Inspect the source and who made each link before using it.
BRON / Matter record02North Harbor · Fact-to-element matrixWhat does the record say about notice?
Requirement§9.2 · Written noticeWritten notice of a defect within 30 days of delivery
Supply agreement · §9.2Supporting record Garcia sent Smith the defect report on May 2.
defect-email.eml · May 2, 2025, 9:14 AMThe send date does not establish receipt or reading.
Adverse account Smith testified the supplier learned of the defect “Only after May 4.”
Smith Dep. 44:12–20Still to establish When did Smith receive or read the email?
Seek Smith’s copy and delivery recordsCompare the testimony
Notice / fact-to-element matrix
Read both accounts.
Supports notice
“Before May 4.”
Garcia deposition · 118:4–12
Recorded testimonyConflicts with it
“Only after May 4.”
Smith deposition · 44:12–20
Recorded testimonyEach account keeps its source. Counsel reviews the notice requirement and whether the timing dispute is material; receipt and reading remain open.
North Harbor · Notice of defect · Illustration · fictional matter Follow a changed foundation.
Accepted factual corrections flag dependent drafts; changed document versions flag tracked reliance in covered work for review.
BRON / Matter record03Source change / affected work
The transcript changed.
One approval is flagged.Smith transcript v1What the proposal relied onSmith transcript v2Errata sheet, May 12, 2026Pending approval · notice analysisFlagged for reviewThe proposed action relied on Smith 44:12–20 of version 1. Read the change before approving.
What the review flags
The daily review flags pending approvals, client updates and research memos that recorded their sources. A new version does not flag finished drafts. The earlier approval of notice memorandum v4 stays on the record.
North Harbor · Notice of defect · Illustration · fictional matter
Related work on the matter
Related work on the matter
- Recorded testimony, admissions and linked exhibits, into the witness’s examination plan.
- Research questions and reviewed claim requirements, alongside the source-linked fact record.
- The source-linked chronology and supporting or adverse fact-to-element links.
- An open evidence question, for a proposed discovery request or a scoped device question.
- Recorded decisions and flags for affected work, into the next review.
Explore one decision in detail
One decision*
The requirement, both accounts and the email between them.
Read the fact-to-element matrix against counsel’s reviewed notice requirement. Agreement §9.2 is the supplied contract reference; no researched holding is supplied. The source dates distinguish the events from the later testimony about them.
Garcia deposition · April 22, 2026 · 118:4–12
Smith deposition · April 24, 2026 · 44:12–20
The timing may bear on notice. Receipt and reading remain the next evidence questions, not established events.
Request for production No. 1 · With Alex for final review before service. Review-meeting notes: not in the named sources; that finding covers the named sources.
Decide whether the timing dispute is material to the reviewed notice requirement. Use the source-linked chronology and original email to scope the receipt or reading question, then plan who could establish it at trial. The request remains for counsel’s review before service.