The supplier could rely on Smith Dep. 44:12 and the absent meeting notes recalled at 118:13–18 to challenge timely written notice. Garcia Dep. 118:4 remains the competing account; neither is resolved here.
Valuation and strategy
Availability: Limited availability
Weigh settlement against trial. Test the position.
Compare settlement and trial economics from the saved model, then challenge pivotal assumptions with war games and the Red Brief.
Availability details
An estimate. Its ranges have not been checked against resolved matters.
What does the range rest on?
Inspect the model and scenario
Smith Dep. 44:12
If Smith’s account prevails
Test the notice assumption against the saved position.
Was written notice of the defect given by May 4, 2025?
“Only after May 4.”Smith deposition · 44:12–20
“Before May 4.”Garcia deposition · 118:4–12
Counsel reviews what each source supports. Neither account decides the notice issue.
“Only after May 4.” Smith Dep. 44:12
Inspect the full product example
Illustrated range, not a fitted distribution. No recalculation is performed in this example.
Inspect the recorded basis and opposing assumption
defect-email.eml · May 2, 2025, 9:14 AM. Sending does not establish receipt.
About this example
Explore this feature
In practice
Test the position before recommending it.
Compare settlement with trial.
Inspect claims, costs, coverage and model freshness alongside the p10–p90 range, a conditional estimate of the case’s economics.
BRON / Valuation01Settlement or trial / saved model
Read the economics
and their basis.Notice / disputed
Two accounts
“Before May 4.” (Garcia Dep. 118:4–12) and “Only after May 4.” (Smith Dep. 44:12–20).
Model basis and limits
Money / costs and coverage
Costs and policy limits
A policy limit caps the range only when every active claim has a known limit.
Five estimates / one range
Five separate estimates
The middle estimate is kept whole, and the number that came back is shown.
The saved model and its freshness support negotiation alternatives and an offer ladder. Figures remain assumptions to review; risk-aversion analysis applies only when enabled. No dollar figures or accepted terms are supplied here.
North Harbor · Notice of defect · Illustration · fictional matter Prepare for the opposing case.
Read the Red Brief’s source-linked opposing argument and run war games to test what changes if the opponent wins a pivotal issue.
BRON / Valuation02Notice / conditional scenario
Ask what changes
if the evidence changes.Recorded accounts
“Before May 4.” Garcia Dep. 118:4–12
“Only after May 4.” Smith Dep. 44:12–20
Evidence still sought
Smith's copy of the May 2 email, its delivery records, and the review-meeting notes
Request for production No. 1 · proposed, not servedScenario, not a result
If new evidence changes the notice assumption, counsel can test how the modeled range responds. When Smith received or read the email.
No scenario figures or outcome are supplied in this illustration.
North Harbor · Notice of defect · Illustration · fictional matter Choose the next proof question.
Use disputed facts and conditional swings to focus discovery before recommending a position; client authority and acceptance remain separate decisions.
BRON / Valuation03War game / opposing case
Test the assumption
before the offer.Pivotal assumption
If Smith's account prevails
“Only after May 4.” · Smith Dep. 44:12–20. A war game can re-run the model under that notice assumption.
Opposing argument and offer
Red Brief / opposing argument
Set that account against “Before May 4.” (Garcia Dep. 118:4–12) and the May 2 email with its attached report. Receipt and reading remain open.
Offer record
An offer is compared with the range recorded that day; it does not change the simulation.
Counsel reviews the cited record and decides the next evidence work. No scenario result or offer terms are supplied here.
North Harbor · Notice of defect · Illustration · fictional matter
Related work on the matter
Related work on the matter
- The saved model and its freshness, into settlement-versus-trial analysis; internal negotiation posture stays attorney work product.
- Open questions in discovery, as reasons the range is wider.
- Each demand and offer, with the range that stood that day.
- Each valuation, recorded before the outcome is known, in a log that is not edited.
Explore one decision in detail
One decision*
Assume timely notice is not established.
An explicit war game re-simulates claims gated by that adverse issue resolution. In a model where timely notice gates North Harbor's recovery, those claims lose their path to recovery in the scenario. This tests the model's dependency, without deciding testimony or the legal requirement.
The generated opposing argument works element by element from supplied record excerpts. A position without a surviving source pin is discarded. Review what changed before adopting any priority.
Request for production No. 1 seeks Smith's copy of the May 2 email, its delivery records, and the review-meeting notes. It remains with Alex for final review before service.
Recorded with the range that stood that day. It does not change the simulation.
Review the base and adverse ranges in the actual war-game result, then choose the receipt or reading evidence to pursue. A scenario does not publish a new headline range. Carry the reviewed requirement to a witness, exhibit and foundation plan before advising the client.