Garcia Dep. 118:4 and Smith Dep. 44:12 disagree about when the supplier knew. Read each answer in its transcript context.
Discovery
Availability: Limited availability
Ask for the evidence that could resolve the dispute.
Turn source-linked gaps into focused requests, review what comes back and carry recorded answers into witness preparation.
Availability details
Discovery review and preparation can be scoped for a pilot. Confirm production-export support and attorney review requirements in writing before using it.
Notice requirement and missing notes
Review-meeting notes: not in the named sources.
“Before May 4.”
“Only after May 4.”
May 2, 2025, 9:14 AM · Garcia → Smith
Request details
Smith's copy of the May 2 email, its delivery records, and the review-meeting notes
May 2, 2025, 9:14 AM · Garcia → Smith
Request details
Smith's copy of the May 2 email, its delivery records, and the review-meeting notes
Inspect the full product example
Inspect the originals and proposed request
About this example
Explore this feature
In practice
Make each discovery step answer a question.
Read the response in context.
Inspect emails, attachments and production references together; where enabled, numbered opposing responses retain their quotations, attribution and objections.
BRON / Discovery01Received set / evidence question
The email arrived.
The question remains.FileReturned April 29, 2026defect-email.emlGarcia to Smith · May 2, 2025, 9:14 AMdefect-report.pdfAttached to emailReview-meeting notesNot in named sourcesStill open
When Smith received or read the email. Garcia recalled notes he did not bring (118:13–18).
Proposed request
Request for production No. 1, proposed and not served, asks the supplier for Smith's copy of the May 2 email, its delivery records, and the review-meeting notes. Missing notes do not prove withholding.
North Harbor · Notice of defect · Illustration · fictional matter Ask for what could resolve the gap.
Focus the next request on an open question or contradiction, and reuse linked opposing answers in the cross-examination plan.
BRON / Discovery02Recorded review decisions
What has been
reviewed so far.Supply agreement.pdfResponsiveDecision recorded · Alex Chen
defect-email.emlReview pendingWith Elena Rivera. Not yet reviewed.
Review-meeting notesOutside this review setNot in the sources the request named, so there is nothing to code.
Coverage not measured yet
Share of the set reviewed
Not measured yet.
Coverage counts the review work that was recorded.
North Harbor · Notice of defect · Illustration · fictional matter Prepare the outgoing work.
Review responses, deficiencies and the proposed production, with privilege and classification checks and approval of the exact set before release.
BRON / Discovery03Outgoing production / counsel review
Held back until
privilege is reviewed.Documentdefect-report.pdfPrivilegeReview requiredClassificationMore protective reading keptProducing itNeeds the attorney’s confirmationProduction held for reviewIt cannot be produced until privilege is reviewed.
North Harbor · Notice of defect · Illustration · fictional matter
Related work on the matter
Related work on the matter
- Recorded opposing discovery answers and their objections, into cross-examination preparation.
- Gaps in a production, as follow-up requests and meet-and-confer letters.
- The meet-and-confer exchange, as the chronology for a motion to compel.
- Each production you serve, in a production log that is not edited.
Explore one decision in detail
One decision*
Two prior accounts, one returned email, an unresolved question.
Supply agreement §9.2 calls for written notice of a defect within 30 days of delivery. Counsel is examining whether written notice was given by May 4, 2025. The disagreement makes receipt, reading and the meeting sequence material questions.
Garcia to Smith · May 2, 2025, 9:14 AM. The report is attached; the email does not show when Smith received or read it.
Garcia recalls notes at 118:13–18. They were not found in the named sources. That result is not proof of withholding.
Ask the supplier for Smith's copy of the May 2 email, its delivery records, and the review-meeting notes. With Alex for final review before service; not served.
Counsel decides whether the proposed request addresses the material uncertainty and whether to prepare a separate examination topic about first receipt or reading. Confirm witness and exhibit links before relying on an assembled examination plan.